<<TBR CHALLENGE: JANUARY 2016>>
It has been silent on the moats of Blue Castle…the water still and unmarred by the movement of crossings, heroes on horse back, steely eyed warriors or were-dragons…
And that’s not to say they haven’t tried – because they have…but they have all been such an enormous pile of uninteresting, unimaginative and just plain UGLY books; that I haven’t been able to lower the portcullis, and let them past the battlements.
The result being ennui of mammoth proportions and a lingering taste of mawkish sentiment, which was really hard to get rid of.
But, salvation presented itself in the form of Wendy, the Super Librarian’s TBR Challenge for January: Short Shorts…
It made me get off my high book-pouting stool (trust me, its a thing) and delve into the scarily ancient depths of my TBR list.
That’s not to say I found books worthy of being housed in the citadel..but at least it allowed me to finish off in quick succession 4 short-ish stories.
And when I say finish off – I mean, I DNF’d 3 of the above, and sacrificially made my way through the 4th. But the important thing is that they ARE NO LONGER in my TBR…
(*Breathes huge sigh of relief*)
The AMNESIA trope is not one I have immersed myself in previously, and (if I am basing my future reading attempts on the above books), probably a path I would be hesitant to venture down again.)
My prior experience with Amnesia:
Things I have learnt from the Amnesia Experience (what we’re now calling it at BlueCastle)
- Heroines tend to wake up in hospital, in a non-regulation, often lacy nightgowns
- Heroines are pale and wan, (but in a completely attractive way), with ‘limpid blue eyes and confused eyelashes’ (that is a direct quote btw)
- Nurses are efficient and sympathetic and romantic of disposition (all the better to help the hero in his dastardly kidnapping plans)
- Heroes are menacing, monosyllabic and often scarred; in one case he had an eye patch…’like a pirate…only more elegant’ (sadly, another quote…)
- Heroes WILL NEVER explain to the heroine what has happened and why they are married to the hero. No, they prefer terrifying silence and innuendo-raising eyebrows to actual explanations.
- Heroines NEVER trust the hero – that’s why the hero isolates them, in jungles, rain forests, large estate homes, castles on cliff edges and ranches.
- Punishing kisses, talk about being wives, in the full sense of the word, and suspicious servants abound.
- Despite the fact the heroes look like they’re one step away from wearing the heroine as a skin suit and pickling their eyeballs for later… ALL WHO KNOW THE HERO think he is upstanding, trustworthy, stalwart and brave.
- Sharp pains behind the eyes, fainting when strong muscly arms are nearby to catch them, and fragmented memories trickle in towards the later end of the books.
- Reluctant heroine falls in love with hero, despite misgivings…
Of course these are all vintage harlequin, perhaps more modern amnesia romances may differ?
A Man like Daintree and Love in a Stranger’s Arms, were both variations on the above dot points…I made it about halfway through each of them, before I folded and threw in the towel.
Daintree was PARTICULARLY painful and purple prose abounded, like a frolicking bunny tail, waltzing it’s way through bluebell covered fields overlooking verdant vistas and a sparkling brook teaming with leaping silver-bellied fishes… (see what I did there? Not even half as bad as Daintree). I kid you not.
This is the opening paragraph:
SHE was alone. All alone in a… rain jungle, yet its beauty seemed to compensate for all else. Forest giants ringed her round, hurtling straight up towards the cobalt chinks of light in a fierce competitive battle for sun and supremacy, wreathed in parasitic vines, the strangling rope-like lianas that twisted and intertwined and made bridgeways for a teeming nocturnal population.
THis is the 3rd paragraph:
She swallowed weakly and gagged a little, reassured by that densely blue patch of sky framed by the leaves. A strange, iridescent insect with huge gauzy wings flitted along her arm. She tried to brush it away but couldn’t. Something was wrong with her arm, but she was in no pain, anaesthetized by shock. Her mind was completely placid, not a ripple to corrugate its unquestioning surface. She tried to turn her head, suffering an unexpected dizzying sense of vertigo, seeking to pierce the high forest galleries its shadowy depths, but it all seemed to close in on her in a swirling, tangled mass of virulent green.
This is when mosquitoes bit the heroine:
A ceaseless hum dinned into her eardrums – mosquitoes. Millions of them, bombarding her tender skin with ravenous appetite. She was a flaming mass of pain, red-hot needles jabbing into the satiny exposed flesh.
This is where Valancy gave up:
“Quite a night, isn’t it?” he murmured with laconic understatement. “No wonder at all the tribes worship the Sky People! Look at the moon – limpid as a pool of gold. Outsize stars, low enough to touch them. There’s one shooting. Make a wish, Andrea!”
Tell me, how does one use an exclamation mark laconically?
Love in a Stranger’s Arms: he of the formidable eye patch and castle on the hill – who married the heroine to save her from prison…something something amnesia…something something…limpid eyes, violent embraces and numerous talkings about running away…something something – valancy done.
The remaining two stories had a slight twist in that it was the men who had caught The Amnesia. This meant they could be assholes and noone would call them on it, and it also placed the heroine in a caretaker role.
Mather’s Images of Love, unfortunately had such HORRIBLE characters, none of whom seemed to notice just how unbearably awful they actually were. I left them in the Carribean, hoping they would all go out on one of those little boats, capsize and get eaten by piranhas… (They inhabit the Carribean right?)
That left lucky ole last:
Game of Hazard, Kate Walker, 1986
This one was like 8 shades of INSANE – but slightly amusing, so I kept going with it.
The entire storyline takes place over 2days – with a weeks break and an extra day thrown in at the end. (Just in case y’all were thinking it all happened too fast…)
So Erin is a knitwear designer. Lives in a cottage far from all reasonable help and returns from the shop to find a man sleeping in her head.
*At this point I am unsure whether we are on the “oh grandma what big teeth you have’ path or are going for a straight up goldilocks…’*
Instead of calling the police like any sane person should, Erin decides to feed him, keep him and suffer through his violent mood-swings, punishing embraces and fevered rejections.
Of course they get snowed in and have uncontrollable chemistry. It must have been pretty powerful stuff, because one almost-seduction involved a knitted sweater emblazoned with red cabbage roses…which I imagined looked something like this:
My Point: These things were not amazingly attractive; proof I suppose of their undeniable twu-wuv..?
Nick of course drops cryptic remarks, hides the truth and treats Erin abominably.
Erin of course beats her tiny fists against his manly chest numerous times and then gives her virginity up to him.
And in good Harelquin fashion, it all works out in the last 6 pages, with everyone living happily ever after and me wondering if that was the LONGEST 186 pages I have EVER read.
Would I read them again?
No. Not even if I was stuck in here-to-fore undiscovered 11th ring of Dante’s Inferno – you know, the one that looks like doctor’s surgery or the DMV, but noone EVER calls your name – and they were the only books left in the world to read.
…not that I have particularly strong feelings about it either way…
But I DO feel self-righteous, vindicated and oh-so-still-keeping-my-new-years-resolutions-ish – and that is what matters.
Valancy – still on the search for a real life example of someone who can be both laconic and exclamative – at the same time. They MUST exist somewhere….
Header Image: Cover Art, Robert McGinnis, False Scent, 1961
7 thoughts on “The World Forgetting by The World Forgot…(or my forgetful (heh) foray into Amnesia)”
What a wonderful review!
I wonder, though, what would it look like, were you to ever have strong feelings about anything… 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much!
FYI…Table Flips are involved in STRONG feelings:
LikeLiked by 2 people
Then we are indeed fortunate none of these books tried your patience to that degree 😀
I swear, some of the things I’ve read described as “he drawled” …
I know! Also: the incorrect use of ‘saunter’ and ‘demurely’ – I was reading a regency that had the heroine yelling demurely..I mean – Really???
This was such a good review! Really enjoyed it. So much that I did a little research on the term of ‘over description’. I was fascinated to read that ‘in the past’ (not quite sure how far in the past), when authors ran out of ideas for their story, particularly if they were writing in installments, they would take their characters off to a picnic in the park or the zoo. At least a chapter or two could be devoted to these outings with pages of descriptions while the author pondered the next twist in the plot. Apparently, “Varney the Vampire’ is a very good example of this!!
Thanks so much – and what you found out about over description is so interesting…and probably explains why the Womans Weekly’s Middletons is still going – LOTS of picnics…and dinner parties! 🙂